Skip to content
🍪 Free Shipping on Orders $100+ (US Only) — Mix & Match: 5, 10, or 20 Cookies
  • Gourmet Cookies
    • Limited Edition Gourmet Cookies
    • Single Retail Gourmet Cookies
    • 12 Pack Gourmet Cookies
    • Secret Stash
    • Snack Size Cookies
  • Protein Cookies
    • Limited Edition Protein Cookies
    • Single Retail Protein Cookies
    • 12 Pack Protein Cookies
    • Protein Secret Stash
    • Protein Snack Size
    • Protein Bite size
  • Threads
  • Protein Pastries
    • Single Protein
    • 12 Pack Protein Pastries
    • 5-Pack Variety Box
  • Join Our Team
Login
My Cookie DealerMy Cookie Dealer
  • Gourmet Cookies
    • Limited Edition Gourmet Cookies
    • Single Retail Gourmet Cookies
    • 12 Pack Gourmet Cookies
    • Secret Stash
    • Snack Size Cookies
  • Protein Cookies
    • Limited Edition Protein Cookies
    • Single Retail Protein Cookies
    • 12 Pack Protein Cookies
    • Protein Secret Stash
    • Protein Snack Size
    • Protein Bite size
  • Threads
  • Protein Pastries
    • Single Protein
    • 12 Pack Protein Pastries
    • 5-Pack Variety Box
  • Join Our Team
0

Invalid Password
Enter
  • Pop-Up Riverhead
  • Who are we?
  • Shipping Info
  • Heating Instructions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Return Policy Clothing
  • Refund Policy Cookies
  • Corporate Gifting
  • Catering
  • Contact us for Wholesale orders
  • BUY E-GIFTCARD
  • Terms of Service
  • Gourmet Cookies
    • Limited Edition Gourmet Cookies
    • Single Retail Gourmet Cookies
    • 12 Pack Gourmet Cookies
    • Secret Stash
    • Snack Size Cookies
  • Protein Cookies
    • Limited Edition Protein Cookies
    • Single Retail Protein Cookies
    • 12 Pack Protein Cookies
    • Protein Secret Stash
    • Protein Snack Size
    • Protein Bite size
  • Threads
  • Protein Pastries
    • Single Protein
    • 12 Pack Protein Pastries
    • 5-Pack Variety Box
  • Join Our Team
Stay Fresh. Get the Drop.

Get first access to limited drops + 10% off your first order.
American Express
Apple Pay
Discover
Google Pay
Mastercard
PayPal
Shop Pay
Visa

© 2026 My Cookie Dealer, All rights reserved. Powered by Shopify

Cart

Your cart is currently empty.

Start Shopping
Trending Now
  • Protein Bite Sized Crunchy Milk & Cookie
    Quick view
    My Cookie Dealer
    Protein Bite Sized Crunchy Milk & Cookie $6.49 /
  • Protein Bite Sized Crunchy Chocolate Chip
    Quick view
    My Cookie Dealer
    Protein Bite Sized Crunchy Chocolate Chip $6.49 /
  • Smooth As Butter PROTEIN
    Quick view
    My Cookie Dealer
    Smooth As Butter PROTEIN $6.50 /